Dear and Gorgeous Nonsense: The Poetic Impulse in Myth

Each month, we explore a theme through weekly MythBlasts, curated works, quotations, etc. This month's theme is Breakthrough.

An abandoned house in Kolmanskop, Namibia, being overtaken by the Namib Desert. Photographed in 2006 by Damien du Toit. CC 2.0 via Wikimedia.

There is something about existence that has been puzzling to human beings, it seems to me, since the beginning of our species: a nagging intuition, an impression—an apprehension, really—that there is much more to life, that something is going on behind the material experience of the world as we understand it. Life is, in its cool objectivity, inherently baffling and stubbornly impenetrable. This quality of inscrutability may certainly inspire curiosity and delight, adventurousness and investigation, but the same impenetrability that inspires such optimism may awaken, in equal amounts, dread and fear.

Schopenhauer and Nietzsche (and, more recently, Emil Cioran and Eugene Thacker) have persistently questioned the perspective of optimism. To dismiss these philosophers as merely nihilistic is to misunderstand their deep connection to life, their magnificent empathy for vulnerability which gives rise to apprehensions about the “normal” sunny orientation to life, and questions conventional thoughts regarding how we “should” feel about it. They have created philosophies that, in important ways, seem to stand against philosophy itself, against epistemological certainty and unfailing optimism, and work to disconcert and disquiet the anthropocentrism that has characterized humanity’s view of the world—a view which has continually seemed to frustrate humanity’s attempts to live in harmony with the conditions of life. Conditions, by the way, that were established long, long before human beings were a presence in the world to bear witness to them, and are sufficiently dark that they must be seen through a poetic lens lest one lapse into complete despair. 

Continue Reading the Mythblast

The Mythic Dimension: Selected EssaysCioran used to refer to himself as “un homme de fragment,” a fragmented man. Life is often a fragmenting force, and one of the principle means of our fragmentation is finding oneself torn between the beguiling charms of Plato’s metaphysical ideal forms which exist in an abstract imaginal  state, and the immediate experience of mind, matter, and consciousness, which we generally refer to as “real.” So, what does one make of this fragmentation, of having one’s mind simultaneously in the real while longing for the ideal? How does one refrain from waging war on life and manage to, as Nietzsche put it, affirm not only oneself, but all existence?

The natural impulse is to devote oneself to one and dismiss the other categorically, thereby avoiding the dissonance of having to entertain two competing psychic realities. Once we’ve dispelled one of these possibilities, we set about trying to perfect the real or, conversely, intensify our investment in, and longing for, the ideal. In The Mythic Dimension, Joseph Campbell notes that the function of art is not “annihilation [of one condition or the other], but celebration.” (275) We are better served by thinking yes/and rather than either/or, privileging the type of thinking reflected in “the true poetry of the poet,” rather than “the poetry overdone of the prophet, and the poetry done to death of the priest.” (Campbell, 26) 

The prophets and the priests tend towards literal, concrete interpretations of mythopoesis; they tend to use substantive language when speaking or writing about God and from that frequent and customary usage, they assume that every substantive idea or expression has an actual, substantial something behind it. Through this overdetermined presumption, they degrade a poetic notion to prosaic pronouncements and come to understand God as an actual thing or being, instead of a metaphor for some ineffable truth. The word god loses its metaphorical nature and is subsequently related to and relied upon as though God is a real entity. Campbell puts it this way:

For if it is true that “God is not like anything: hence no one can understand him by means of an image,”…then it must be conceded, as a basic principle of our natural history of the gods and heroes, that whenever a myth has been taken literally its sense has been perverted; but also, reciprocally, that whenever it has been dismissed as a mere priestly fraud or a sign of inferior intelligence, truth has slipped out the other door. (36)

Mythopoesis, true poetry, is the foundation of religious thought; regrettably, the poetry of religion is, as Campbell noted, “done to death” by the clergy and rendered unimaginative, uninspired, concretized dogma. The poetic impulse inspires what William James described as the potential for the “ontological wonder” and “cosmic emotion” conveyed by religion, and similarly, it lives in the heart of the first function of myth which, Campbell says, is to “waken and maintain in the individual an experience of awe, humility, and respect, in recognition of that ultimate mystery, transcending names and forms, ‘from which,’ as we read in the Upaniṣads, ‘words turn back.’” (Masks of God, Vol. IV: Creative Mythology, 830)

Poetry allows us to glimpse the ideal while still rooted in the real. It gives us the double vision we need to make sense of this terrifying and fascinating mystery of existence—mysterium tremendum et fascinans, as Rudolph Otto put it—and see in it an attitude of play, the divine play of spirit, the play of the élan vital, the dynamism of life itself. Nobility of spirit, the supremely aristocratic point of view, Campbell says, is “the ability to play, whether in heaven or on earth,” (The Mythic Dimension, 36) and always accompanying play are its daughters, laughter and delight. Play clarifies and unburdens; it lightens the load and often transforms judgement into appreciation. For example, Samuel Taylor Coleridge affectionately called Plato’s philosophy “dear, gorgeous nonsense,” and Lionel Trilling called Finnegans Wake “transcendent genial silliness…” that in its way, “keeps the world in its right course…” (The Last Decade: Essays and Reviews 1965-75, 33) 

Humans come and go. Of course we are mortal, of that there can be no pretending, and as such, we must perish. But play itself is immortal, constantly refreshing itself with new players, and one can sense how, if we stand with one foot in the real and one foot in the ideal—the posture of divine play—we may glimpse the transcendent truth. It’s understandable, isn’t it, that this two-footed standpoint, the double-vision that mythopoesis confers, allows us to revel and play in and among both of these realms? The poetry of myth is such that we can embrace the immanence of the transcendent, Platonic vision without sacrificing empirical reality, and with affectionate good humor say, I love this dear, gorgeous nonsense of life!

Best regards,

Bradley Olson, Ph.D.

About Brad 

Bradley Olson, Ph.D., is the editor of the Joseph Campbell Foundation’s MythBlast series. Dr. Olson is a Depth Psychologist in private practice in Flagstaff, Arizona; his work with clients is heavily influenced by his interest in Jungian Analytical Psychology, literature, and Mythological Studies.


Weekly Quote

I think of mythology as the homeland of the muses, the inspirers of art, the inspirers of poetry. To see life as a poem and yourself participating in the poem is what the myth does for you.

-- Joseph Campbell

Featured Work

The Mythic Dimension

The Mythic Dimension

These twelve essays explore the topic for which Campbell was best known: the many connections between myth and history, psychology, and everyday life. Drawing from such varied sources as Thomas Mann, the occult, Jungian and Freudian theory, and the Grateful Dead, these dynamic writings elucidate the many ways in which myth touches our lives, our psyches, and our relationship to the world.

Book Club

The Mwindo Epic from the Banayanga
Edited and translated by Daniel Biebuyck and Kahombo C. Mateene

“The Mwindo Epic from the Banayanga is a classic Nyanga tale about a confident young hero named Mwindo and his search for the father who wronged him. As we follow Mwindo on his journey from the depths of the Underworld to the zeniths of Space, we see that this is more than a hero’s genesis story; it’s a tale that examines the very meaning of heroism. Traditionally told orally, and in this iteration led by our narrator, Rureke, The Mwindo Epic, uses song, voice, dance, and the narrator’s personality to make this a myth that feels alive and dynamic every step of the way.

“A classic of African literature, The Mwindo Epic from the Banayanga is a poetic tale of adventure, heroism, humility, and the rich culture of the Nyanga people.”

Torri Yates-Orr
Editorial Advisor Group
Joseph Campbell Foundation

Monthly Gift

Theology, Love, Troubadours, and Minnesingers (Esingle from Romance of the Grail)

Our gift to you this month is eSingle. Access this download for free until the end of the month.

The twelfth-century in Europe was a time of change, growth, and conflict. The Western individualistic tradition of romance and heroism challenged the norms of medieval society, as poets and singers attempted to find a middle path between love (amor) and orthodoxy (Roma).

This short ebook is a chapter from. Romance of the Grail: Magic and Mystery of Arthurian Legend.

News & Updates

It is November, and the Coast Salish People stow their canoes and put their paddles away. In other news:

October 31, November 1, and November 2 can be referenced in the English language by a single word: “Allhollowtide.” These holidays embrace the shared theme of death which begins on Halloween (or All Hallows’ Day, as the Western Church would have it), continue through the memorial of the largely martyred saints on All Saints day, and conclude with All Souls’ Day. Candles lit.

The joyful counterpart to to those last two events, Día de los Muertos, is also celebrated in Mexico and other parts of Latin America on November 1 and 2.

Diwali [11/4] (meaning “a row of lamps”) begins five days of joyous celebration observed by Hindus, Sikh, and Jains in fond recollection of the triumph of Good over Evil. Offerings are made to goddesses Kali and Lakshmi. The next day, November 5, Vikram New Year 2078 begins for Hindus and Jains.

The Birth of the Báb, Herald of the Bahá’u’lláh, on November 6 is a joyous festival among the observant Bahá’ís who abstain from work in his honor. From the perspective of the Westerner, the Báb fulfills the archetype of John the Baptist, heralding the coming of one greater.

Featured Video

Psyche & Symbol - Apollonian vs Dionysian Dichotomy

(see more videos)

[caption id="attachment_23351" align="aligncenter" width="1024"] An abandoned house in Kolmanskop, Namibia, being overtaken by the Namib Desert. Photographed in 2006 by Damien du Toit. CC 2.0 via Wikimedia.[/caption] There is something about existence that has been puzzling to human beings, it seems to me, since the beginning of our species: a nagging intuition, an impression—an apprehension, really—that there is much more to life, that something is going on behind the material experience of the world as we understand it. Life is, in its cool objectivity, inherently baffling and stubbornly impenetrable. This quality of inscrutability may certainly inspire curiosity and delight, adventurousness and investigation, but the same impenetrability that inspires such optimism may awaken, in equal amounts, dread and fear. Schopenhauer and Nietzsche (and, more recently, Emil Cioran and Eugene Thacker) have persistently questioned the perspective of optimism. To dismiss these philosophers as merely nihilistic is to misunderstand their deep connection to life, their magnificent empathy for vulnerability which gives rise to apprehensions about the “normal” sunny orientation to life, and questions conventional thoughts regarding how we “should” feel about it. They have created philosophies that, in important ways, seem to stand against philosophy itself, against epistemological certainty and unfailing optimism, and work to disconcert and disquiet the anthropocentrism that has characterized humanity’s view of the world—a view which has continually seemed to frustrate humanity’s attempts to live in harmony with the conditions of life. Conditions, by the way, that were established long, long before human beings were a presence in the world to bear witness to them, and are sufficiently dark that they must be seen through a poetic lens lest one lapse into complete despair. 

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *