The Blooming of Truth: Campbell on the Mythic Past

Each month, we explore a theme through weekly MythBlasts, curated works, quotations, etc. This month's theme is Blooming.

Once Upon a Midnight Dreary. Illustration to The Raven by Edgar Allan Poe. Édouard Manet, 1875. Public Domain.

Edgar Allan Poe once wrote a little piece called “The Imp of the Perverse,” and I do believe that there must be in the fashioners of piously held beliefs, all over the world, an exceptionally strong strain of the faculty and impulse that he there describes; for it cannot be that they do not know what they are doing. Neither can it be that they regard themselves as deceivers. Nevertheless, they are seldom satisfied merely to brew for the moral nourishment of mankind an amusing little beer of what they know to be their own apocryphal fantasy, but they must needs present their intoxicant with deliberately pompous mien as the ambrosia of some well of truth to which they, in their state of soul, have been given access. It is exactly as my author, Poe, has said. “All metaphysicianism,” as he terms such work, “has been concocted a priori. The intellectual or logical man, rather than the understanding or observant man, set himself to imagine designs —to dictate purposes to God. Having thus fathomed, to his satisfaction, the intentions of Jehovah, out of these intentions he built his innumerable systems of mind.” And with a curious strain of the same perversion by which the sages teach their designs, both vulgar and the learned everywhere have been forever loath to see any such facts brought to light as might tend to inform them of the true nature of the brews by which they live, dream, and regulate our lives.

The Masks of God: Oriental Mythology 518-519

Although we tend to think of the Campbellian enterprise of Mythological Studies as providing honey-sweet “positive” content for our lives, passages like the ones above tell a slightly different story, more critical of the positivity of mythic ideology. As a consequence of this double task, both affirmative and critical, any piece of mythological studies issues a call to confront the traumatic truths of our mythic past, the composition of the brew of our national ideology, forcing us to come face to face with the imp of the perversity of mythic consciousness.  

In “The Imp of the Perverse,” Poe anticipates such notions of depth psychology, later developed by Freud and Jung, as the Id (The Thing) and the Shadow. With this level of psychoanalytic insight, Campbell can easily explain to himself the “curious strain of the same perversion by which the sages teach their designs,” and the great resistance of “both vulgar and the learned everywhere” to “forever loathe […] any such facts brought to light as might tend to inform them of the true nature of the brews by which they live, dream, and regulate our lives” – Namely, the true nature of what we adopt as our “personal mythology”: the stories we tell ourselves about ourselves which are mostly lies. 

Continue Reading the Mythblast

For it is generally acknowledged that if we want to get to know someone, we cannot base our judgement solely on what this individual thinks about herself; Instead, we must turn to the content of this person’s actions in order to know their true character. Sometimes these self-serving fantasies are crushingly belittling, sometimes narcissistically self-aggrandizing, but any sympathetic observer and listener would recognize at once the perversity of such “personal mythology.”

What is true of the individual is also true of entire nations and their mythic pasts. We all have to deal with the imp of perversion at the heart of our founding narratives. For without this shadow work, without this making conscious of the unconscious lie, the true blooming of mythology cannot come to pass.

As with the psychotherapy of the individual so it is with entire nations; the problem is not so much the “creation of a new myth” but the elimination of repressive elements that block the spontaneous outpouring of mytho-historic truth. This is the reason that a well-trained psychotherapist will refrain from providing “answers” or assigning “meaning” to an individual’s life, no matter how much they may beg for it. A significant part of working through the transference, the spontaneous co-dependence of the patient to the analyst, is to free the individual from this delusion. For it is taken for granted that delusions are never good for the life of the soul. 

“Truth is the ultimate repressed,” as Wolfgang Giegerich states in The Soul’s Logical Life (217).

What is ultimately repressed in the depths of the psyche is not some mysterious “self“ waiting in the wings, nor is it the intensity of sexuality, but a painful truth that speaks at the place where the psyche must enter the flesh. For there is the existential rub, the irrepressible edge of the symptom, where the unconscious mind forces itself upon the conscious ego and breaks down all its defense mechanisms. 

So when we advocate for the “non-binary” logic of myth as the logic of both/and over against either/or, we should not forget the full implication of this proposition: that the logic of both/and must include either/or as its internal complementary opposition. Otherwise we remain caught in the literal split of external opposites. True myth thus operates through the logic of both/and and either/or, following the paradoxical logos of the soul, as an upsurge of the mythic imagination into the material light of history.

Hence, we would do myth a disservice were we to relegate it to the purely metaphoric or personal realm of make-believe and wish-fulfillment—where we can have everything both ways and speak out of both corners of our mouths. No, that is not the true nature of myth but the work of the imp Campbell and Poe warned us about. If we believe that myth truly matters, on the other hand, we must turn to the material truth of its existential mystery. It is when myth is allowed to bloom in truth that it becomes living history.

 

Discuss this MythBlast with the author, Dr. Norland Tellez, in our forums: Join us in Conversations of a Higher Order.

Yours,

Norland Tellez, PhD

Norland TellezNorland Tellez is an artist and teacher with over 20 years of experience in the animation industry. He graduated from CalArts in 1999 and went on to work as a 2D animation artist for Walt Disney Feature Animation as well as Warner Brothers. He also completed a Masters and Doctorate degrees in the study of mythology at Pacifica Graduate Institute with a dissertation on the Popol-Vuh, a classic of Mayan mythology. He was the recipient of the Joseph Campbell Research Grant in 2006.

As a writer and director, Norland has helped to produce award-winning educational properties, most notably the Once Upon a Sign mini-series for DawnSignPress and SignWorldTV, which features deaf actors using American Sign Language with voice-over acting.

As a teacher of Life Drawing and other animation-related fields, Norland has taught at CalArts and Santa Monica Academy of Entertainment and Technology, as well as the Art Institute of California Los Angeles.

Find out more at NorlandTellez.com

 


Weekly Quote

Life as an art and art as a game––as action for its own sake, without thought of gain or of loss, praise or blame––is the key, then, to the turning of living itself into a yoga, and art into the means to such a life.

-- Joseph Campbell

Featured Work

The Masks of God 2: Oriental Mythology

In the second volume of the Masks of God series, Campbell offers an explanation of Eastern mythology as it developed into the distinctive religions of Egypt, India, China, and Japan.

“The myth of eternal return, which is still basic to Oriental life, displays an order of fixed forms that appear and disappear through all time.”

– Joseph Campbell

Book Club

“In Old Path, White Clouds, we find ourselves moving through Buddha’s eminent journey towards Nirvana. We shall find our conscientious being during the voyage, breathing new life into our hearts and minds…

– Prabarna Ganguly, Ph.D.
Editorial Advisory Group
Joseph Campbell Foundation

Monthly Gift

Freud Jung & Kundalini Yoga Part 1 (Audio: Lecture II.4.1)

Our gift to you this month is audio lecture. Access this download for free until the end of the month.

“One can take anything – this watch – draw a ring around it. Forget that you know how to use it. What is it? The mystery of the being of this object is exactly the same as the mystery of the being of the universe.” — Joseph Campbell

In part 1 of this 3 part lecture, Joseph Campbell brings together the fundamentals of Kundalini Yoga and modern depth psychologists. He lays the foundation of the chakras and other major eastern perspectives before delving into western perspectives in part 2.

This lecture was recorded at the Esalen Institute in 1966.

News & Updates

Jains begin a nine-day festival on Monday, April 19, during which they venerate the Navpads or nine “posts” of the faith.

Tuesday’s Festival of Riḍván, the Bahá’í “Great Festival,” recalls Bahá’u’lláh’s declaration of his divine mission.

For eight days, observant Hindus have been reading the epic of Rama who is recognized as the seventh incarnation of the god Vishnu, celebrating his birthday on Wednesday, April 21.

In the Eastern Christian tradition, the story of Lazarus is proclaimed initiating the same sequence of ritual events already celebrated in the Western Christian churches a month prior.

Featured Video

POM - A New Mythology - The Earth

(see more videos)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *